Sienna Miller With Messy Bun vs. Curly-Haired Melissa Benoist

Please subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates from Your Next Shoes. This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure for more details.

Two hot stars, two hot looks. Both Sienna Miller and Homeland actress Melissa Benoist wore all-black ensembles for their “Late Show with Stephen Colbert” interviews on October 26. So, we have to know: Who wore it better?

Melissa Benoist curls her hair for an interview on "Late Night with Stephen Colbert"Melissa Benoist curls her hair for an interview on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert at the Ed Sullivan Theatre in New York on October 26, 2015

Melissa, the lead actress in the latest superhero TV series “Supergirl,” talked with Stephen about her character serving as a feminist role model.

Melissa Benoist wears a strapless black cocktail dress in New York CityMelissa Benoist wears a strapless black cocktail dress in New York City

For her interview, she wore a strapless black cocktail dress with a slit paired with Brian Atwood “Patty” d’Orsay pumps.

Melissa Benoit's feet in Brian Atwood pumpsMelissa Benoit’s feet in Brian Atwood pumps

Brian Atwood Patty Patent Pumps

Brian Atwood Patty Patent Pumps

Sienna, on the other hand, went a little more boho-chic for her interview.

Sienna Miller wears her blonde hair in a messy bun for an appearance on "Late Night with Stephen Colbert"Sienna Miller wears her blonde hair in a messy bun for an appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on October 26, 2015, in New York

The actress paired a black Roland Mouret dress with block-heeled sandals to promote her upcoming movie “Burnt.”

Sienna Miller wears a camel coat over a Roland Mouret dress in New York CitySienna Miller wears a camel coat over a Roland Mouret dress in New York City

She tossed a three-button camel coat over her ensemble.

Sienna Miller's feet in block-heeled sandalsSienna Miller’s feet in block-heeled sandals

We think Melissa wins this round. What about you? Steal Supergirl’s style with a pair of half d’Orsay pumps.

Jessica Simpson Claudette Pump, $42.95 – $84.99

Jessica Simpson Claudette Pump

Or go for 90’s boho-chic with a pair of block heel sandals like Sienna.

Marni Black Jewel Block Heel, $955

Marni Black Jewel Block Heel

Credit: Patricia Schlein / C.Smith / WENN