America’s Got Talent Shoe Showdown: Which Judge Wore the Hotter Heels?

Please subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates from Your Next Shoes. This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure for more details.

We recently featured Heidi Klum showing off her new favorite Saint Laurent pumps at two separate ‘America’s Got Talent’ events, but she wasn’t the only AGT judge we’ve spotted with noteworthy heels.

Mel B also attended the two red carpet events for the talent show on July 23 and 24, wearing show-stopping heels both nights. At the first event, the former Spice Girl posed in a turquoise Selfish by Forever Unique fitted dress that featured alluring cutouts with gold chain trimming. She completed the look with glamorous curls and Jimmy Choo “Anouk” metallic pumps.

mel b AGT pre show event

'Americas Got Talent' Season 8Mel B at a pre-show red carpet event for America’s Got Talent in New York City on July 23, 2013

Jimmy Choo Anouk Heel in SilverJimmy Choo “Anouk” Pumps in Metallic Silver, $650 at Saks Fifth Avenue

At the second event on July 24, Mel rocked a Unique Heroes studded mini dress with Giuseppe Zanotti sandals. (It’s a bit difficult to tell from the photo, but her sandals feature sculpted gold plates at the heels, making them quite eye-catching.) She finished her second look with a creative updo and a few pieces of standout jewelry.

mel b AGT post show event

'America's Got Talent' Season 8 Post-Show Red Carpet EventMel B at a post-show red carpet event for America’s Got Talent in New York City on July 24, 2013

GIUSEPPE ZANOTTI Plated Heel Tie-Front Sandal $1,250 Outstep
Giuseppe Zanotti Metal Plate Sandals, $625

Now, let’s look back at how Heidi wore her Saint Laurent “Janis” t-strap pumps on the ‘America’s Got Talent’ red carpet.

heidi klum saint laurent janis tstraps

'Americas Got Talent' Season 8Heidi Klum at two red carpet events for America’s Got Talent in New York City on July 23 and 24, 2013

We love the sleek versatility of these classic Saint Laurent pumps, but we’re still not sure they work with both of Heidi’s dresses.

saint laurent janis t strap pumps blackSaint Laurent “Janis” T-Strap Platform Pumps, $709

So, who wore the hotter heels? It’s a tough call! However, we’re leaning more toward Mel B simply because she showed us some variety.

Credit: Michael Carpenter/Pop/WENN

DO YOU LOVE SHOES? Win free shoes, organize your shoe closet, see the latest styles + more

Curr Cat
© Copyright Your Next Shoes 2010 - 2023 | Back to Top