Who Wore It Better? Ashley Madekwe vs. Willow Shields in Self Portrait

Please subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates from Your Next Shoes. This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure for more details.

Ashley Madekwe was one of the celebrities who brought a lot of style to the usually relaxed atmosphere of the San Diego Comic-Con.

The ‘Salem’ actress managed to find the perfect balance between her upscale style and the laid-back vibe of the event with her matching separates. Her checkered black and white knotted top and matching high-waisted culottes ensemble were especially fetching.

But wait, haven’t we seen this look before? The matching separates from the brand Self Portrait was first spotted on Willow Shields at the Nickelodeon 28th Annual Kids’ Choice Awards. Who do you think looked better wearing this look?

1. Ashley Madekwe’s Classic Elegance

Ashley Madekwe shines in a stylish black and white gingham ensemble at Comic-Con International 2015Ashley Madekwe shines in a stylish black and white gingham ensemble at Comic-Con International 2015 on July 10, 2015, in San Diego, California (Credit: Tony Forte / WENN / FayesVision / Adriana M. Barraza)

The actress tamed the loudness of the matching top and pants by accessorizing with simple pieces like her thin-strapped sandals and black clutch. We also love how she styled her hair in big, vintage-style curls.

2. Willow Shields’ Playful Twist

Willow Shields impresses in black and white Self-Portrait with purple Louboutin pumps at the Kids' Choice AwardsWillow Shields impresses in black and white Self-Portrait with purple Louboutin pumps at the Kids’ Choice Awards (Credit: Tony Forte / WENN / FayesVision / Adriana M. Barraza)

The actress added fun to the look by wearing purple Christian Louboutin pumps and a matching purple clutch.

Willow Shields looks radiant with soft waves in her blonde hair and a natural makeup look, highlighting her fresh and youthful glow at the Nickelodeon 28th Annual Kids' Choice AwardsWillow Shields looks radiant with soft waves in her blonde hair and a natural makeup look, highlighting her fresh and youthful glow at the Nickelodeon 28th Annual Kids’ Choice Awards on March 28, 2015 (Credit: Tony Forte / WENN / FayesVision / Adriana M. Barraza)

We think both ladies rocked the Self Portrait matching top and culottes. Ashley went classic, while Willow gave it a more youthful vibe. Both pieces have sold out:

Self Portrait Mono Checked Cropped Top and CulottesSelf Portrait Mono Checked Cropped Top, £85.00 / Self Portrait Mono Checked Culottes, £110.00