Prints are lovely, even more so when they’re bright and rich, but there’s no denying those classic achromatic or neutral hues are the most versatile for scarves.

Celebrities like Halle Berry, Sophie Monk, and Katie Holmes have recently opted for such color-less extras to cap off their winter outfits – Halle in a classic black scarf while fetching her daughter from school, Sophie in a textured open weave extra while grabbing some coffee in West Hollywood, and finally, Katie in a two-tone grey neck warmer while heading to a hotel for a meeting in New York City.

Interestingly, all three sightings happened yesterday. Now, between these three lovely ladies, whose scarf style do you think looks the best?

While Halle looks cool in her get-up, and Katie’s parka+pumps+scarf combo is surprisingly chic, we’d have to say Sophie wins this contest, don’t you think so?

Not only are we crushing on her uber-unique white extra, but pairing it with an all-black outfit and super-high booties made a huge difference. She looked fabulous, and judging from the pics, she knew it too!