Sarah Michelle Gellar has been busy on the press circuit promoting her upcoming movie Ready or Not 2: Here I Come, while showcasing an array of styles—from a flirty, daring Nensi Dojaka mini dress paired with Jimmy Choos to vintage glam in Self-Portrait and Louboutins.
Sarah Michelle Gellar promotes Ready or Not 2: Here I Come in New York City on March 17, 2026, switching between crisp white Christian Louboutin “Hot Chick” pumps and sleek black Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” heels (Credit: Roger Wong / INSTARimages)
The 1990s scream queen is returning to the genre with a comedic twist in the sequel to the 2019 film Ready or Not, starring alongside Samara Weaving, Kathryn Newton, Elijah Wood, Shawn Hatosy, and David Cronenberg.
Directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett, the film is set to hit theaters on March 20.
Sarah Michelle Gellar Sharpens Daytime Glam in White Christian Louboutin “Hot Chick” Pumps
For her The View appearance, Sarah wore white Christian Louboutin “Hot Chick” pumps in glossy patent leather, which completely elevated her look and gave it that perfect balance of classic Hollywood and polished daytime style.
The bright white shade popped against her look, lending a crisp, retro polish that echoed the timeless appeal seen on stars like Reese Witherspoon and Selena Gomez, who have both embraced the silhouette on the red carpet. What truly sets the design apart is the signature scalloped topline—its curved edges soften the pointed toe’s sharpness, creating a sculpted, feminine frame that feels more distinctive than a classic pump.
The low-cut vamp and sharply tapered toe work together to elongate the leg, a defining feature of the Christian Louboutin “Hot Chick” style, while the 4-inch stiletto heel adds height and a subtle dose of drama without disrupting the shoe’s clean, refined lines.
These Christian Louboutin pumps retail for $945 and are available in a range of colors and finishes at Nordstrom and Mytheresa.
Sarah Michelle Gellar wears a pair of white Christian Louboutin “Hot Chick” pumps featuring a scalloped topline, pointed toes, and stiletto heels (Credit: Roger Wong / INSTARimages)
Retro Precision: Sarah Michelle Gellar Styles Polka-Dot Self-Portrait Dress with Crisp White Pumps
Sarah Michelle Gellar perfectly paired her white pumps with a black-and-white polka-dot dress from Self-Portrait, instantly giving retro vibes. The print alone already leaned vintage, but paired with the sleek silhouette, it felt updated rather than costumey.
It also featured a one-shoulder neckline that added just enough sultry edge, showing a bit of skin. I really liked how the ruching at the waist subtly shaped Sarah’s body, creating a flattering hourglass effect. It hugged her frame in all the right places, then tapered to mid-calf, making the whole look feel refined yet relaxed.
You can get the maxi version of this dress for $520 (from $650) at Revolve.
Sarah Michelle Gellar embraces retro glamour, pairing her white Louboutin pumps with a black-and-white polka dot one-shoulder dress by Self-Portrait (Credit: Roger Wong / INSTARimages)
Diamond Accents and Soft Glam Balance the Structured Retro Silhouette
Sarah Michelle Gellar’s accessories were simple, wearing a pair of statement earrings, a few rings, and bracelets, including the $33,330 Carrera Y Carrera Riviere Rocio bracelet, made in 18k white gold and set with 47 diamonds totaling 6.67 carats.
Her hair and makeup sealed the deal. Soft blonde waves and natural glam, paired with pink lipstick, kept everything fresh and approachable!
Sarah Michelle Gellar adds sparkles to her retro polka dot look with diamonds, including a Carrera Y Carrera Riviere Rocio bracelet (Credit: Roger Wong / INSTARimages)
Switching Gears: Sarah Michelle Gellar Steps Out in Black Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” Pumps at Watch What Happens Live
Earlier that same day, Sarah Michelle Gellar was spotted outside the Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen studio, and she was definitely commanding attention in a bold, flirty look. She stepped out in a daring Nensi Dojaka mini dress paired with sleek Jimmy Choo heels, and I loved how the whole outfit looked confident and modern, with just the right amount of edge.
She slipped into the Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” pumps, which have been everywhere lately, even spotted on Priyanka Chopra at the Oscars and Olivia Rodrigo at the Vanity Fair Oscar Party.
Sarah wore them in glossy black satin, and they added that perfect polished finish to her flirty ensemble. The pointed toes and high-cut vamps helped elongate her legs, while the 4.7-inch stiletto heels gave her that extra lift. I liked the stitched band detail across the toe and back, which gave the shoe more structure, while the D’Orsay side cut showed the contour of her foot, adding a hint of allure.
Retailing for $850, the Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” pumps are available in multiple colors and finishes—browse current variations at Farfetch and Mytheresa.
Sarah Michelle Gellar steps out in black Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” pumps with stitched band across the pointed toe and back outside Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen studios (Credit: Roger Wong / INSTARimages)
’90s Edge Returns: Nensi Dojaka’s Strappy “Sacha” Mini Dress Adds Structure and Seduction
Sarah Michelle Gellar paired the pumps with the Nensi Dojaka “Sacha” mini dress, which carried the Albanian-born, London-based fashion designer’s signature ’90s-inspired, body-conscious aesthetic.
The strappy design and cutouts showed just enough skin, giving the look a flirty, confident edge. I could see the intricate construction, with exposed boning, padded cups, and a mix of halter and spaghetti straps that held everything in place.
The layered panels made the dress even more interesting. Sheer tulle in soft brown and white was wrapped around the bodice, adding dimension and a bit of contrast while still keeping that sultry vibe. The bottom half was a simple black mini skirt, but the sheer tulle underlay peeking out at the hem added a slightly unexpected finish. If you’re curious, this dress is on sale for $1,354 (from $1,935) at Mytheresa.
Gellar kept her accessories minimal yet fun, wearing jewelry such as the $7,000 Sanamama Innerspace-Ship Ring.
Sarah Michelle Gellar pairs her Jimmy Choos with a flirty Nensi Dojaka mini dress featuring exposed boning, halter straps, sheer tulle wrap, and a mini skirt (Credit: Roger Wong / INSTARimages)
More of Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Best Shoe and Style Moments
From sharp pointed pumps to playful minis and polished premiere looks, Sarah Michelle Gellar has built a fashion track record that balances classic femininity with just the right amount of edge. Explore more of her standout shoe and style moments on Your Next Shoes below.
👠 Explore Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Best Shoe & Fashion Moments:
- 📏 Standing at 5’2″ (157.5 cm) and wearing a US shoe size 7, Sarah Michelle Gellar’s height-and-heels feature highlights how pointed pumps, platform heels, and polished red carpet styling help sharpen her petite frame.
- 🎬 At the 2025 I Know What You Did Last Summer premiere, she delivered whimsical glamour in orange Le Silla pumps paired with a butterfly-inspired dress.
- 🤍 Her The Girl in the Pool LA premiere look paired a white Shushu/Tong mini dress with feminine detailing for a playful, romantic red carpet moment.
- ✨ At TrevorLIVE LA, she wore a Rebecca Taylor dress with glitter platform pumps for a youthful, polished evening look.
- 🖤 Her 2013 Summer TCA party appearance featured studded Jimmy Choo “Anouk” pumps that added edge to an all-black silk-and-leather outfit.
- 👠 While promoting Ringer in New York City, she switched between B Brian Atwood pumps and Christian Louboutin heels, showing off two very different approaches to statement footwear.
- 📚 She also appears in YNS’s roundup of stylish petite celebrities, spotlighting her height, shoe size, and one of her standout Christian Louboutin peep-toe moments.