When it came to Pretty Little Liars red carpets, the stars didn’t just deliver drama on screen — their style moments spoke volumes, too.
From statuesque Shay Mitchell (5’7½”, US 8.5) in sleek stilettos to petite Lucy Hale (5’1”, US 7) in sky-high platforms, the Pretty Little Liars cast proved how height and shoe choice shaped their style. Troian Bellisario (5’7”, US 9) kept it polished in classic pumps, Sasha Pieterse (5’5½”, US 7.5) leaned feminine, and Ashley Benson (5’3½”, US 7) added edge with bold statement heels.
Together, their different heights and shoe choices perfectly showcased how footwear can shape — and elevate — personal style. This makes their group appearance at the PaleyFest panel for Pretty Little Liars in Los Angeles on March 16, 2014, an especially stylish throwback worth revisiting.
Posing together in coordinated black and white outfits, the Pretty Little Liars cast looks glamorous, with each actress showcasing her unique style and choice of heels, from Lucy Hale’s towering platforms to Shay Mitchell’s classic pointed pumps (Credit: C. Smith / Andres Otero / Brian To / WENN)
Among the standout style moments from the PaleyFest panel, Ashley Benson captured attention with her fashion versatility — shifting effortlessly from feminine elegance to menswear-inspired edge.
Throwback: Ashley Benson’s PaleyFest Style Switch-Up
Ashley Benson has always had a knack for reinventing her look. At just 24, she brought effortless sophistication to the PaleyFest panel for Pretty Little Liars in Los Angeles, proving she could pivot seamlessly from playful to polished with her fashion choices.
Ashley Benson exuded a feminine charm, amplified by her casually tousled hair
Her white Alberta Ferretti dress with a peplum and a ruffled layer gave off a dainty, girly vibe, matched by her effortlessly tousled hair.
Ashley Benson wore a delicate white Alberta Ferretti dress featuring a peplum and ruffled layer
Ashley Benson was elegantly dressed in a white Alberta Ferretti dress with 3/4 sleeves, featuring a layered peplum waist at the PaleyFest panel for ‘Pretty Little Liars’ in Los Angeles on March 16, 2014
Ashley wore Bionda Castana “Rosario” pumps. The white scallops contrasted perfectly with the black ankle ties, making this design stand out.
The ankle ties added an unexpected yet welcome element to an otherwise simple pair of pumps.
Ashley Benson shows off her feet in Bionda Castana’s “Rosario” pumps
Just two days later, Ashley took her style from Los Angeles to New York, proving her range once again as she stepped out for the Pretty Little Liars season finale screening in a bold, menswear-inspired look.
Ashley Benson’s Menswear-Inspired Look at the Pretty Little Liars Season Finale
Lucy Hale, Sasha Pieterse, Ashley Benson, Shay Mitchell, and Troian Bellisario pose for a group photo
Her menswear-inspired look wowed everyone. Inspired by Angelina Jolie, Ashley wore a full tux with a Paule Ka top, a black Max Mara jacket, and Alexander Wang cropped black pants.
Ashley Benson channeled a menswear-inspired vibe, donning a Max Mara jacket paired with a Paule Ka top (Credit: C. Smith / Andres Otero / Brian To / WENN)
The oversized Saint Laurent bow tie made this look a memorable one. That and Ashley’s hairdo gave the outfit a feminine touch.
The standout oversized Saint Laurent bow tie gave Ashley Benson’s look an edgy twist (Credit: C. Smith / Andres Otero / Brian To / WENN)
Ashley Benson wears Alexander Wang cropped black trousers and Jimmy Choo pumps at the Pretty Little Liars season finale screening event at the Ziegfeld Theater in New York City on March 18, 2014 (Credit: C. Smith / Andres Otero / Brian To / WENN)
Ashley opted for a refreshing twist, choosing navy suede Jimmy Choos instead of the more predictable black shoes. The iconic “Anouk” pumps have pointy toes and spike heels, adding elegance to Ashley’s masculine suit.
Ashley Benson shows off her feet in navy Jimmy Choo “Anouk” pumps (Credit: C. Smith / Andres Otero / Brian To / WENN)
Beyond Ashley Benson’s contrasting style choices, the Pretty Little Liars cast has delivered plenty of memorable shoe and fashion moments over the years. From red-carpet glamour to off-duty chic, their looks continue to inspire fans and fashion followers alike.
More Pretty Little Liars Shoe & Style Highlights
👠 Explore Your Next Shoes’ Pretty Little Liars Style & Shoe Features:
- 📏 Lucy Hale Marks PLL’s 10th Anniversary in Effortlessly Chic Denim & Statement Tee — Lucy Hale’s casual-chic look featuring Converse sneakers and sleek street-style vibes.
- 📏 Lucy Hale’s Pretty Little Liars Style Evolution: From Aria to Red Carpet Glam — A deep dive into Lucy’s red-carpet footwear like Brian Atwood “Besame” pumps and more PLL-era styling.
- 📏 Pretty Little Liars Cast Shines on the Red Carpet for 100th Episode Celebration — Showcasing sexy heels from Sasha Pieterse, Shay Mitchell, Troian Bellisario, Ashley Benson, and others.
- 📏 Sasha Pieterse Rocks Mocha Mousse Corset with Chic Michael Kors Croc Mules — Sasha’s look featuring Michael Kors “Jessa” croc mules and PLL connection.