Red Carpet Shoe Highlights from Us Weekly’s “Most Stylish New Yorkers”: Jenny McCarthy Leads in Burgundy Alexander Wang Pumps

Back in September 2013, New York’s fashion scene gathered under one glittering roof for Us Weekly’s “Most Stylish New Yorkers” bash. This celebration promised high-glamour moments and unforgettable red carpet turns. With the city’s style elite in attendance, we anticipated nothing less than show-stopping ensembles worthy of the title.

While not every look delivered the sartorial punch we’d hoped for, the evening still offered a handful of standout moments. From daring plunging necklines to statement heels in bold colors and intricate detailing, these celebrities each brought their own twist to the red carpet.

Many years later, it’s a stylish snapshot of the era — a reminder of how trends evolve, how designer favorites endure, and how some looks remain timeless. Let’s revisit the fashion highlights and see which star-studded styles still turn heads.

1. Daring in White: Jenny McCarthy’s Plunging KaufmanFranco Gown & Burgundy Alexander Wang Pumps

Jenny McCarthy turns heads in a plunging white KaufmanFranco dress paired with burgundy Alexander Wang ‘Sabine’ pumps at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash in New York City on September 10, 2013 (Credit: Ryan / Andres Otero / WENN)

Jenny McCarthy (5’5¾” / US 8) commanded attention in a white KaufmanFranco gown, its daring deep-plunging neckline injecting a bold, risqué edge into the otherwise minimalist silhouette.

The sleek cut flattered her frame, while the crisp white hue allowed her burgundy Alexander Wang pumps to stand out as a statement finish.

A close-up of Jenny McCarthy’s feet reveals her intricate rose tattoo, beautifully complemented by the rich burgundy suede and mesh detail of her Alexander Wang ‘Sabine’ pumps

She styled the revealing dress with Alexander Wang’s mesh-and-suede “Sabine” pumps. Zoë Kravitz also wore these heels to the “The Dark Knight Rises” premiere in New York City.

2. Floral Elegance: Brooke Shields’ J. Mendel Dress & Embellished Black Sandals

Brooke Shields stuns in a white J. Mendel dress with bold blue floral embroidery, paired with black ankle-strap heels at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Brooke Shields (5’10½” / US 10.5) brought a burst of garden-inspired elegance in a white J. Mendel dress with bold blue floral embroidery. She paired the look with black ankle-strap sandals adorned with delicate flower embellishments, adding a whimsical touch to her statuesque frame.

While the sandals were charming, a sleek pair of pointed-toe pumps might have better showcased the dress’s intricate embroidery without drawing the eye away from its artistry.

A close-up of Brooke Shields’ black ankle-strap sandals highlights the delicate floral embellishments, which add a charming, whimsical touch to her statuesque frame

3. Bold Contrast: Daisy Fuentes’ Red Prada Pumps & Flowing Navy Skirt

Daisy Fuentes looks elegant in a satin halter top paired with a navy flowy skirt and bold red Prada pumps at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Daisy Fuentes (5’8½” / US 9) exuded effortless elegance in a satin halter top paired with a long, flowy navy skirt.

The fluid silhouette moved beautifully with her statuesque frame, while bold red patent Prada pumps peeked out from beneath the hem, adding a striking pop of color and a polished, high-gloss finish to her look.

A close-up of Daisy Fuentes’ striking red patent Prada pumps peeking from beneath her navy skirt, highlighting the bold color contrast and high-gloss finish that made them the statement piece of her ensemble

Her striking red patent Prada pumps provided a bold pop of color that beautifully contrasted her flowing navy skirt. Their high-gloss finish and sleek silhouette made them the statement piece of her ensemble. Daisy was one of the best-dressed stars of the night.

4. Statement Details: Marysol Patton’s Sheer Lace Top & Ornate Ankle-Strap Heels

Marysol Patton makes a bold statement in a sheer lace top and fitted black pants, accessorized with a fluffy black handbag and sleek ankle-strap heels at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Marysol Patton (5’4½” / US 7.5) made a bold entrance in a sheer lace top paired with fitted black pants, accessorized with a fluffy black handbag.

While the look leaned heavily on drama, the standout element was undoubtedly her black ankle-strap pumps featuring antique-style buckles. This refined detail added a touch of vintage elegance to an otherwise mismatched ensemble.

A close-up of Marysol Patton’s black ankle-strap pumps reveals the standout feature of her look: ornate, antique-style buckles that add a touch of vintage elegance to her ensemble

5. Edgy All-Black: Rocsi Diaz in Lace Christian Louboutin ‘Pigaresille’ Pumps

Rocsi Diaz rocks a chic all-black ensemble featuring a sheer blouse with ruffle detailing and a sleek leather mini skirt, paired with pointed-toe heels at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Rocsi Diaz (5’1¾” / US 6) proved that head-to-toe black can be anything but basic, stepping out in a sleek sheer blouse with ruffle accents, a leather mini skirt, and the ultimate power accessory — Christian Louboutin’s “Pigaresille” pumps.

A sultry twist on the iconic Pigalle, the Pigaresille features a pointed toe, a soaring stiletto heel, and the signature red sole, all wrapped in a seductive black fishnet lace overlay on mesh. The delicate suede piping and heel counter added depth and texture, making these heels the perfect femme fatale finish to her edgy yet elegant ensemble.

Notable wearers include Kiernan Shipka, who paired them with a chic floral RED Valentino dress at the Justin Bieber: Believe premiere, and Khloé Kardashian, who sported the heels at a basketball game, adding sophistication to her black ensemble.

Jessica Chastain wowed in a red dress paired with Christian Louboutin Pigaresille pumps at Paris Fashion Week. The iconic mesh and suede shoes completed her chic and polished look. The ‘Pigaresille’ pumps are also available with shorter (100 mm) heels.

A close-up of Rocsi Diaz’s Christian Louboutin ‘Pigaresille’ pumps reveals their intricate black fishnet lace overlay, delicate suede piping, and signature red sole—a sultry twist on the iconic Pigalle heel

Who do you think was the most stylish celeb at the Us Weekly bash?

More Iconic Shoe Moments From These Stylish Stars

From red carpet power suits to playful Crocs pairings, the celebrities who graced Us Weekly’s “Most Stylish New Yorkers” bash have served up many memorable fashion moments over the years. Explore some of their standout looks below, each showcasing their unique approach to style and footwear.