The Most Stylish Celebs at Us Weekly’s “Most Stylish New Yorkers” Party: Jenny McCarthy Steals the Show

Please subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates from Your Next Shoes. This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure for more details.

We were eager to see what the celebrities would wear when we learned that Us Weekly was hosting the “Most Stylish New Yorkers” bash. Given the event’s focus on style, we expected attendees to showcase their most fashionable looks.

Sadly, we were left disappointed and underwhelmed. Maybe we were expecting too much, or maybe they’re just saving their best for the upcoming Oscars. We’ll have to wait and see.

As the evening unfolded at Club Harlow, a handful of attendees truly stood out with their stylish ensembles, each interpreting fashion in their own unique way. Let’s take a closer look at the celebrities who made a lasting impression on the red carpet:

1. Jenny McCarthy Dazzles in White KaufmanFranco Dress and Alexander Wang ‘Sabine’ Pumps

Jenny McCarthy turns heads in a plunging white KaufmanFranco dress paired with burgundy Alexander Wang 'Sabine' pumps at the 'Most Stylish New Yorkers' bashJenny McCarthy turns heads in a plunging white KaufmanFranco dress paired with burgundy Alexander Wang ‘Sabine’ pumps at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash in New York City on September 10, 2013 (Credit: Ryan / Andres Otero / WENN)

Jenny McCarthy’s white KaufmanFranco gown was daring with its deep plunging neckline, which added a bold, risqué element to the otherwise minimalist design. However, the excessive reveal of cleavage shifted the focus away from the sophisticated silhouette, leaving the look feeling slightly unbalanced.

Jenny McCarthy showcases her feet and intricate rose tattoo in brown suede ankle-strap heelsJenny McCarthy showcases her feet and intricate rose tattoo in brown suede ankle-strap heels

She styled the revealing dress with Alexander Wang’s mesh-and-suede “Sabine” pumps. Zoë Kravitz also wore these heels to the “The Dark Knight Rises” premiere in New York City.

Alexander Wang “Sabine” PumpsAlexander Wang “Sabine” Pumps, $148

2. Brooke Shields Stuns in Floral J. Mendel Dress With Embellished Black Sandals

Brooke Shields stuns in a white J. Mendel dress with bold blue floral embroidery, paired with black ankle-strap heels at the 'Most Stylish New Yorkers' bashBrooke Shields stuns in a white J. Mendel dress with bold blue floral embroidery, paired with black ankle-strap heels at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Brooke Shields complemented her bold, blue floral J. Mendel dress with black ankle-strap sandals adorned with delicate flower embellishments. While the sandals added a whimsical touch, a sleek pair of pointed-toe pumps might have better highlighted the elegance of the dress without distracting from its intricate embroidery.

The American actress wore a pair of black ankle-strap sandals with flower embellishments on the toe caps. We think a simple pair of pumps would’ve been a better choice for her gorgeous floral J. Mendel dress. What do you think?

Brooke Shields completes her look with black ankle-strap sandals featuring floral embellishmentsBrooke Shields completes her look with black ankle-strap sandals featuring floral embellishments

3. Daisy Fuentes Impresses With Bold Red Prada Pumps and Flowing Navy Skirt

Daisy Fuentes looks elegant in a satin halter top paired with a navy flowy skirt and bold red Prada pumps at the 'Most Stylish New Yorkers' bashDaisy Fuentes looks elegant in a satin halter top paired with a navy flowy skirt and bold red Prada pumps at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Daisy Fuentes looked elegant and chic in her long, flowy skirt and top.

A close-up of Daisy Fuentes' striking red Prada pumps peeking out from beneath her navy skirtA close-up of Daisy Fuentes’ striking red Prada pumps peeking out from beneath her navy skirt

Her striking red patent Prada pumps provided a bold pop of color that beautifully contrasted her flowing navy skirt. Their high-gloss finish and sleek silhouette made them the statement piece of her ensemble. We think Daisy was one of the best-dressed stars of the night. Do you agree?

Prada Patent Pumps in RedPrada Patent Pumps in Red, $650

4. Marysol Patton Turns Heads in Sheer Lace Top and Ornate Ankle-Strap Heels

Marysol Patton makes a bold statement in a sheer lace top and fitted black pants, accessorized with a fluffy black handbag and sleek ankle-strap heels at the 'Most Stylish New Yorkers' bashMarysol Patton makes a bold statement in a sheer lace top and fitted black pants, accessorized with a fluffy black handbag and sleek ankle-strap heels at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Real Housewives of Miami’s Marysol Patton outfit caught our eyes for all the wrong reasons. We like the antique-looking buckles on her black ankle-strap pumps, but that’s pretty much all we like about her ensemble.

A close-up of Marysol Patton's black ankle-strap heels featuring ornate buckle detailingA close-up of Marysol Patton’s black ankle-strap heels featuring ornate buckle detailing

5. Rocsi Diaz Rocks Edgy All-Black Ensemble With Lace Christian Louboutin ‘Pigaresille’ Pumps

Rocsi Diaz rocks a chic all-black ensemble featuring a sheer blouse with ruffle detailing and a sleek leather mini skirt, paired with pointed-toe heels at the 'Most Stylish New Yorkers' bashRocsi Diaz rocks a chic all-black ensemble featuring a sheer blouse with ruffle detailing and a sleek leather mini skirt, paired with pointed-toe heels at the ‘Most Stylish New Yorkers’ bash

Rocsi Diaz opted for a sleek all-black ensemble, demonstrating that simplicity doesn’t mean sacrificing style. Her outfit, while understated, made a powerful statement of elegance and edge, landing her among the evening’s most stylish attendees.

A close-up of Rocsi Diaz's lace-patterned pointed-toe heelsA close-up of Rocsi Diaz’s lace-patterned pointed-toe heels

Her lace-patterned Christian Louboutin “Pigaresille” pumps and edgy ensemble looked great. Several celebrities have showcased their love for Christian Louboutin’s Pigaresille pumps, known for their signature lace and mesh design.

Notable wearers include Kiernan Shipka, who paired them with a chic floral RED Valentino dress at the Justin Bieber: Believe premiere, and Khloe Kardashian, who sported the heels at a basketball game, adding sophistication to her black ensemble.

Christian Louboutin "Pigaresille" 120 mm PumpsChristian Louboutin “Pigaresille” 120 mm Pumps, $795

Jessica Chastain wowed in a red dress paired with Christian Louboutin Pigaresille pumps at Paris Fashion Week. The iconic mesh and suede shoes completed her chic and polished look. The ‘Pigaresille’ pumps are also available with shorter (100 mm) heels:

Christian Louboutin “Pigaresille” 100 mm PumpsChristian Louboutin “Pigaresille” 100 mm Pumps, $750

Who do you think was the most stylish celeb at the Us Weekly bash?