Ashley Greene’s Sophia Webster Pumps at the 2015 Vanity Fair Oscar Party: A Polished Look That Divided Critics

On February 22, 2015, at the Vanity Fair Oscar Party held at the Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts in Beverly Hills, Ashley Greene stepped into a fashion moment that continues to spark discussion—particularly for its footwear choice—alongside fellow attendees including Christina Aguilera, Emma Stone, Miley Cyrus, Irina Shayk, Diane Kruger, Beyoncé, Jennifer Lopez, and Rosie Huntington-Whiteley.

Ashley Greene did not impress fashion critics in a macramé lace dress by Rachel Roy and sophisticated makeup at the 2015 Vanity Fair Oscar Party in Beverly Hills on February 22, 2015 (Credit: WENN / Brian To / Dennis Van Tine / Future Image)

Sophia Webster Pumps Anchor Ashley Greene’s Vanity Fair Look

Wearing a macramé lace dress by Rachel Roy styled with understated Kismet jewelry, Greene let her footwear do the real talking—finishing the look with pointed-toe Sophia Webster “Lauren” pumps that reflected the designer’s early red-carpet ascent.

Launched in 2012 after an apprenticeship with Nicholas Kirkwood, the Sophia Webster brand quickly became known for pairing classic silhouettes with playful, high-impact details, making Greene’s choice a noteworthy snapshot of mid-2010s red-carpet shoe trends.

Measuring 5 feet 4 ¾ inches (164.5 cm), Ashley Greene arrived at the 2015 Vanity Fair Oscar Party in a look that was undeniably polished—but one that ultimately struggled to resonate with fashion critics.

While her Rachel Roy macramé lace dress and pointed-toe Sophia Webster pumps were refined and well-styled, the ensemble appeared on several worst-dressed lists for its familiarity and restrained impact at one of Hollywood’s most high-profile events.

Ashley Greene sharpens her intricate Rachel Roy macramé lace dress with sleek pointed-toe Sophia Webster “Lauren” pumps, letting the minimalist heels balance the gown’s ornate texture at the 2015 Vanity Fair Oscar Party

Much of the criticism centered on the dress itself, which closely echoed a nearly identical Rachel Roy look previously worn by Kim Kardashian in March 2014. On an Oscar night red carpet—where originality and spectacle are often expected—revisiting a silhouette already associated with another celebrity was widely viewed as a missed opportunity rather than a bold style statement.

The overall tone of the outfit also felt subdued for the occasion. Critics noted that the knee-length macramé lace dress carried more of a daytime or cocktail sensibility, lacking the drama typically associated with the Vanity Fair party’s glittering, fashion-forward atmosphere. Even with sleek hair, elegant makeup, and metallic accessories, the look was frequently described as safe rather than memorable.

That said, Greene’s affinity for Sophia Webster remains well documented. A longtime fan of the brand, she previously stepped out in cream Sophia Webster “Coco” pumps paired with a vibrant pink Giambattista Valli dress at the 2014 Global Green USA Pre-Oscar Party—a styling choice that better captured the designer’s playful edge and demonstrated how bold footwear can elevate a red-carpet look.

A black suede Sophia Webster “Lauren” pump finished with a signature heart-shaped heel detail, blending classic elegance with the designer’s playful, romantic edge

Standout Shoe Moments From the 2015 Vanity Fair Oscar Party

To see how other A‑listers brought their fashion A‑game to the same star‑studded event, explore these standout shoe moments from the 2015 Vanity Fair Oscar Party: