Jennifer Lopez’s “The Boy Next Door” Faces Backlash for Age Difference

Please subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates from Your Next Shoes. This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure for more details.

In January 2015, Jennifer Lopez was busy with promotional duties for her new movie, The Boy Next Door, released in the United States on January 23, 2015.

She stars as the newly divorced woman Claire Peterson in the American erotic psychological thriller film that is inspired by a true story.

Jennifer Lopez clips her hair back as she arrives for a guest appearance on "The Wendy Williams Show"Jennifer Lopez clips her hair back as she arrives for a guest appearance on “The Wendy Williams Show” in New York City on January 20, 2015 (Credit: TNYF / WENN / Cousart / JFXimages)

Barbara Curry, a former criminal lawyer, wrote the screenplay for the film based on her life experiences. In the movie, Jennifer Lopez’s character is seduced by her 19-year-old teenage neighbor, Noah Sandborn (Ryan Guzman).

Ryan Guzman’s Role and Age Comparison

Most of the filming took place in Los Angeles during the fall of 2013, when Ryan Guzman was 26 years old, despite playing a character who is supposed to be 19. He was 27 when the movie was released in January 2015.

Ryan Anthony Guzman was born in Abilene, Texas, on September 21, 1987, and turned 26 on September 21, 2013. His co-star, Jennifer Lopez, was 44 years old while filming The Boy Next Door.

26-year-old Ryan Guzman on the set of 'The Boy Next Door' in November 201326-year-old Ryan Guzman on the set of ‘The Boy Next Door’ in November 2013 (Credit: TNYF / WENN / Cousart / JFXimages)

During an interview on On Air With Ryan Seacrest, Jennifer Lopez admitted that filming sex scenes was challenging and described them as awkward and uncomfortable. Still, she emphasized the importance of making them appear real while maintaining professionalism to avoid workplace complications.

“They’re awkward and a little bit uncomfortable, but you try to get into it to make it real,” Lopez revealed. “I like keeping it professional. I don’t need it to get messy at work.”

ABC News criticized Ryan Guzman’s casting as a high school student, comparing it to the absurdity of casting Keith Richards as an Olympic gymnast. They also remarked that while Jennifer Lopez is a great entertainer, her acting in “The Boy Next Door” was only adequate, suggesting that she needed to deliver a stronger performance for the movie to succeed.

“If you’ve ever seen Ryan Guzman, the very notion that this 27-year-old actor would play a high school student seems like an idea for a comedy sketch. It’s like casting Keith Richards to play an Olympic gymnast. Also, Jennifer Lopez is a terrific entertainer but she’s only an adequate actress. In order for “The Boy Next Door” to work, she needs to be, at the very least, a good actress,” ABC News wrote in their scathing review of the movie.

Ryan Guzman turned 26 while filming The Boy Next Door as 19-year-old Noah SandbornRyan Guzman turned 26 while filming The Boy Next Door as 19-year-old Noah Sandborn (Credit: Universal Pictures)

Barbara Curry’s Inspiration for the Film

Barbara Curry explained to Cosmopolitan that the original story was much simpler. It began with her admiration for a house she frequently ran past and wanted to buy. She later discovered that a troublesome boy, her son’s schoolmate, lived across the street from that house.

“Well, initially it wasn’t this story — it was much tamer. It really started because there was this house. I’m a runner and would run by this house, and I always admired it. One day, I saw that it was up for sale, and I talked to my husband, and I said, “We should put a bid in. This is my dream house.” I found out later that a boy my son was going to school with lived across the street from that house. This boy was kind of a “bad boy: He was always getting in trouble, possibly getting kicked out of school, you know, stuff like that,” Barbara Curry said about the story.

Jennifer Lopez stars as Claire Peterson in the erotic psychological thriller film The Boy Next DoorJennifer Lopez stars as Claire Peterson in the erotic psychological thriller film The Boy Next Door (Credit: Universal Pictures)

“And I wondered, If we lived in this house, that boy is going to live right across the street from my son, and I bet you they’re going to become friends, and will this boy influence my son? Friends are so important to kids. And I just could imagine all the things that could go wrong with that. Because of that, we did not even try to buy the house, ” she added.

“Then I thought it was a really interesting idea, this concept that a neighborhood boy could cause conflict and drive a wedge between a family. The first few drafts of [the movie] focused on a 12-year-old boy and a mother’s trial of trying to get her son out of this boy’s clutches, and gradually, it became something else. Then there was the decision to have [the two characters] sleep together. Of course, then I had to make the boy a lot older.”

Jennifer Lopez’s Promotional Appearances

After appearing on Good Morning America, the then-45-year-old actress headed to The Wendy Williams Show to tape an episode.

Jennifer Lopez signs autographs for fans as she arrives at "The Wendy Williams Show"Jennifer Lopez signs autographs for fans as she arrives at “The Wendy Williams Show” (Credit: TNYF / WENN / Cousart / JFXimages)

She looked gorgeous in a black ensemble with an understated trench coat, a silk pleated dress that fell below her knees, and a black fur scarf wrapped around her neck.

Jennifer Lopez's feet in Giuseppe Zanotti ankle-strap pumpsJennifer Lopez’s feet in Giuseppe Zanotti ankle-strap pumps (Credit: TNYF / WENN / Cousart / JFXimages)

She completed her look with a pair of Giuseppe Zanotti suede pumps, which have buckled ankle straps, pointed toes, about one-inch platforms, and 4.75-inch heels.

Black Giuseppe Zanotti Platform PumpsBlack Giuseppe Zanotti Platform Pumps, $725.52

The “Booty” singer left the studio wearing another black number — a knee-length black dress styled with a metallic gold belt, a black coat, and hoop earrings.

Jennifer Lopez wears an all-black cinched-waist look as she leaves "The Wendy Williams Show"Jennifer Lopez wears an all-black cinched-waist look as she leaves “The Wendy Williams Show” (Credit: TNYF / WENN / Cousart / JFXimages)

She traded her Zanotti heels for a pair of sheer pumps by Kurt Geiger.

Jennifer Lopez signs autographs for fans in an all-black lookJennifer Lopez signs autographs for fans in an all-black look (Credit: TNYF / WENN / Cousart / JFXimages)

These four-inch pumps, called the “Sharkie,” feature sheer side panels with crisscrossing details, suede toe caps and heel counters, and self-covered heels.

Jennifer Lopez's feet in sheer Kurt Geiger heelsJennifer Lopez’s feet in sheer Kurt Geiger heels (Credit: TNYF / WENN / Cousart / JFXimages)

Kurt Geiger "Sharkie" Sheer Cap Toe PumpsKurt Geiger “Sharkie” Sheer Cap Toe Pumps, $550