Ready or Not 2 Rome Premiere: Kathryn Newton’s Red Louboutin “So Kate” Pumps vs. Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Black Jimmy Choos

Kathryn Newton (5ft 5¼ / 165.7 cm) and Sarah Michelle Gellar (5ft 2 / 157.5 cm) continued their Ready or Not 2: Here I Come press tour style streak at Casina Valadier in Rome, both leaning into the polished pump formula that has defined their recent appearances on Your Next Shoes.

While Newton has been sharpening her fashion identity with a steady rotation of sleek, leg-lengthening heels—seen in earlier press stops featuring Jimmy Choo and Rodo pumps during the Ready or Not 2 press tour—Gellar has stayed true to her signature contrast styling, often reworking classic silhouettes with darker accents, including her go-to Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” pumps across multiple appearances.

At the Italian premiere, both opted for timeless dresses paired with pointed pumps—but their height difference subtly shifted the visual impact, with Newton’s taller frame enhancing the fluidity of her monochrome look, while Gellar’s petite proportions emphasized structure and contrast in her black-and-ivory ensemble.

Newton stood out in a bold red dress from The New Arrivals, paired with matching red Christian Louboutin pumps for a clean monochromatic look.

Gellar went for something more minimal in a white Bec + Bridge dress with black Jimmy Choo pumps, adding a sharp contrast. Their shoes completed their outfits in different ways: one blending in seamlessly, the other adding definition.

Kathryn Newton and Sarah Michelle Gellar attend the Ready or Not 2: Here I Come premiere at Casina Valadier on March 23, 2026, in Rome, Italy, showcasing contrasting red-and-ivory looks styled with classic pointed pumps (Credit: Anna Maria Tinghino / Future Image / Cover Images)

🔴 Head-to-Toe Impact: Kathryn Newton Stuns in Red Christian Louboutin “So Kate” Pumps & The New Arrivals Velvet Dress

Kathryn Newton stepped out in an all-red look that instantly caught my attention. Even on the red carpet, her outfit stood out rather than blending in, which I think says a lot about how well everything was put together.

For footwear, she wore red Christian Louboutin “So Kate” pumps, which added to the sultry vibe of the look. The pumps featured towering 4.7-inch stiletto heels, sharp pointed toes, and low vamps that helped create a flattering, longer leg line. The low-cut sides revealed a bit of the foot, adding a more daring, sleek touch to the overall design.

Newton paired the heels with red tights, creating a seamless, head-to-toe finish. I honestly wasn’t sure about them at first, but I ended up liking how they added a subtle retro feel and a bit more personality to the look, making it less predictable.

Kathryn Newton slips into a pair of shiny red Christian Louboutin “So Kate” pumps and daring red tights (Credit: Anna Maria Tinghino / Future Image / Cover Images)

Kathryn wore the skintight red “Paulo” dress by The New Arrivals, which highlighted her slim figure. It had a scoop-neck, tank-style bodice that hugged her waist and hips before flaring at the hem into a dramatic peplum.

That flouncy, flared detail added volume and movement, balancing out the fitted silhouette nicely. The scarlet silk velvet fabric looked rich and luxe, complementing her radiant complexion beautifully and making the color stand out even more.

Newton wore her blonde hair down, straightened, and swept over one shoulder, adding softness to the bold look. Her makeup stayed in the same tone with rosy cheeks and lips, tying everything together.

To finish, Kathryn added sparkle with Grown Brilliance rings, including a 2-carat round lab-grown diamond twist band, a marquise tapered baguette cocktail ring, and a delicate tennis necklace, bringing in just enough shine.

Kathryn Newton pairs her red pumps and tights with a red velvety dress by The New Arrivals, featuring a form-fitting tank-style bodice with a scoop neck and a fitted skirt with dramatic peplum-like hem (Credit: Anna Maria Tinghino / Future Image / Cover Images)

⚫ High-Contrast Elegance: Sarah Michelle Gellar Pairs Black Jimmy Choo Pumps with an Ivory Bec + Bridge Dress

Sarah Michelle Gellar leaned into contrast for a modern, slightly edgy look that still kept a feminine touch. Compared to Kathryn Newton’s bold red moment, Sarah took a different approach, balancing soft ivory with sharp black accents. I have to say, I actually liked how the mix of light and dark added more dimension to her outfit.

She wore the Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” pumps, a style that’s been making the rounds lately. The same pair has been spotted on Olivia Rodrigo, Priyanka Chopra, and Nikki Glaser during awards season, and Sarah has actually worn them before, which shows how easy they are to style.

Made from glossy satin, the pumps featured a sleek pointed toe, a curved topline, and a high-cut vamp that hugged the foot nicely. The 4.7-inch stiletto heel added height, while the stitched band across the toe and back gave the design more structure and definition. You can get them for $895 at Farfetch.

Sarah Michelle Gellar wears the Jimmy Choo “Brigitte” pumps in black satin with a curved topline, pointed toes with stitched band, and stiletto heels (Credit: Anna Maria Tinghino / Future Image / Cover Images)

To create contrast, Sarah Michelle Gellar paired the black pumps with a $350 ivory Bec + Bridge “Amelie” strapless dress. Its column silhouette was simple and straight, though a bit unflattering and relaxed, but the details made up for it.

The skirt had a semi-sheer effect with vertical shredded textures that revealed subtle glimpses of her legs, adding a soft, sultry element. It also featured a strapless bodice with an elasticated neckline and a built-in bodysuit, keeping everything secure while still looking clean and elegant.

What I liked most were the white 3D fabric floral details scattered across the dress. They added texture and depth, giving the otherwise minimal piece more visual interest. The skirt slightly covered her shoes, but you could still catch glimpses of the black pumps underneath.

Gellar styled her blonde hair in loose, tousled waves that gave off a relaxed, beachy vibe. To finish, she wore pearl earrings by Nancy Newberg, along with a few rings and a tennis bracelet, adding a soft sparkle. Her red lipstick brought in a subtle pop of color, tying everything together.

While the black pumps did add a bit of weight to the look, the contrast worked, giving her outfit a sharper, more defined finish.

Sarah Michelle Gellar teams her black satin pumps with a strapless white Bec + Bridge “Amelie” column dress with 3D florals and a skirt with vertical shredded textures (Credit: Anna Maria Tinghino / Future Image / Cover Images)

More Red Christian Louboutin and Black Jimmy Choo Moments Worth Revisiting

From Kathryn Newton’s head-to-toe red Christian Louboutin statement to Sarah Michelle Gellar’s sharp black Jimmy Choo contrast, this premiere offered two polished takes on the enduring power of classic pumps.

For more standout celebrity looks built around red Louboutins and black Jimmy Choo heels, revisit these evergreen fashion and shoe moments on Your Next Shoes: