Back in March 2017, Melissa Benoist stepped onto the carpet at The Paley Center for Media’s “Heroes & Aliens” presentation during PaleyFest at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood.
Standing 5ft 6¾ (169.5 cm) tall, the American singer and actress—best known for her breakout role as Marley Rose on Glee before soaring to stardom as the lead in Supergirl and appearing in films like Whiplash—reportedly wears a US shoe size 8.5.
While she may embody an “unattainable, idealistic optimist” on screen, her real-life fashion choices prove she’s unafraid to experiment—even if her 2017 PaleyFest look left fans divided.
Pair a structured Chinese-inspired silk set with bold red suede pumps for a statement look, balancing tradition with modern edge
Melissa Benoist Experiments With Pajama-Inspired Style and Bold Red Mansur Gavriel Pumps
Sure, her black-and-maroon, Chinese-inspired silk top and cropped trousers may have suited the casual, comic book–themed occasion—and they certainly offered a refreshing break from her spandex superhero costume.
Still, the look leaned heavily into pajama territory, blurring the line between loungewear and red carpet.
To complete the ensemble, Melissa stepped into bold red suede pumps by Mansur Gavriel, a daring choice with their square-toe boxes and block heels. While unconventional, the shoes injected a pop of color and a touch of edge that kept the outfit from feeling too relaxed.
Melissa Benoist’s hairstyle features sleek, straight locks with a center part, creating a polished and modern look
Melissa Benoist’s Other Shoe Choices: A Mix of Elegance and Edge
Melissa Benoist has consistently showcased her eclectic taste in footwear, complementing her diverse fashion choices. For instance, during an appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, she donned a strapless black cocktail dress paired with Brian Atwood’s “Patty” d’Orsay pumps, highlighting her penchant for classic elegance.
In another instance, at the world premiere of the TV series Waco, Melissa opted for blush velvet ankle-strap sandals to complement her pink Solace London one-sleeved midi dress, demonstrating her ability to blend contemporary styles with a touch of softness.
These choices underscore her versatility and keen eye for pairing the perfect shoe with each ensemble.
Melissa Benoist at The Paley Center for Media’s 34th Annual PaleyFest presentation of The CW’s “Heroes & Aliens” held at Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, California, on March 18, 2017 (Credit: FayesVision / WENN)
Why Celebrities Love Mansur Gavriel
Mansur Gavriel has become a favorite among celebrities, with Margot Robbie stepping out in their chic suede mules, adding a touch of elegance to her ensemble. Similarly, Suki Waterhouse was spotted at LAX, effortlessly pairing her outfit with Mansur Gavriel’s d’Orsay heels, showcasing the brand’s versatility.
Even Taylor Swift embraced the brand’s minimalist aesthetic, complementing her all-white ensemble with a tan Mansur Gavriel shoulder bag.
Close-up of Melissa Benoist’s bold red Mansur Gavriel suede pumps with low block heels, adding a vibrant pop of color to her pajama-inspired PaleyFest look
What do you think of Melissa Benoist’s outfit? Would you say yay or nay?
We spotted Emma Roberts in similar-looking Chloe “Harper” pumps a few days earlier at Paris Fashion Week, and she made her pair look cute. Perhaps Melissa could take notes from Emma, or maybe she needs the chic Parisian atmosphere.
If you can rock these quirky pumps, browse the various colors of Melissa Benoist’s Mansur Gavriel ballerina pumps at Farfetch:
Mansur Gavriel Ballerina Pumps in Red Suede, $390
Mansur Gavriel Ballerina Pumps in Sand Suede, $475
Mansur Gavriel Ballerina Pumps in Pink Suede, $390
Mansur Gavriel Ballerina Pumps in Black Suede, $475
Mansur Gavriel Ballerina Pumps in Red Leather, $474
Mansur Gavriel Ballerina Pumps in Black Leather, $474
Melissa Benoist’s PaleyFest ensemble was certainly a conversation starter, blending structured silk with bold red suede pumps. While her outfit may have leaned more toward loungewear than luxury, it showcased her willingness to take fashion risks. Her choice of Mansur Gavriel ballerina pumps may not have been a universal hit, but they undeniably added a pop of color to her look.