Do Stana Katic and Mischa Barton Look Alike? A Double-Take in Red-Carpet Heels

Do Stana Katic and Mischa Barton look alike—or are we just seeing double? Maybe it’s their pronounced jaws, sculpted cheekbones, or shared statuesque elegance. Either way, their resemblance is uncanny—and it’s not just in the face.

In this style comparison, we’re breaking down two of their standout red-carpet looks and exploring how both actresses use fashion and footwear to highlight their striking features.

Stana Katic (left) and Mischa Barton (right) share strikingly similar bone structure, each favoring minimalist glam looks that highlight their sculpted cheekbones and defined jawlines (Credit: Joel Ginsburg / Alberto Reyes / Apega / FayesVision / SIPA / WENN)

Mischa Barton, the British-American actress celebrated for her breakout role as Marissa Cooper in The O.C., stands at 5 feet 9 inches (175.3 cm) and wears a US shoe size 9.

Similarly, Stana Katic—best known for playing Detective Kate Beckett on Castle—shares the same height and shoe size, often accentuating her statuesque frame with elegant high heels that amplify her polished, red-carpet poise.

Backgrounds and Beginnings: Stana Katic and Mischa Barton

Stana Katic, born on April 26, 1978, in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, is older than Mischa Barton, born on January 24, 1986, in Hammersmith, London, England.

Ethnically, Katic has Serbian roots in Croatia. She describes her heritage as Dalmatian, with family origins in Croatia’s Vrlika and Sinj areas. She is fluent in several languages, including Serbian, and holds U.S. citizenship.

Stana Katic stuns in a hot-pink Versace mini dress and matching pointed pumps, while Mischa Barton opts for understated elegance in a gold Rubin & Chapelle gown layered with a white cardigan and neutral heels

Mischa Barton, on the other hand, has a mixed English and Irish background. Born in the UK to an English father and an Irish mother, Barton moved to the U.S. at five. She identifies closely with her Northern Irish heritage, noting a special connection to the area. Barton holds both British and American nationalities.

Fashion on the Red Carpet: Stana and Mischa’s Distinct Styles

At the New York premiere of her Showtime series Masters of Sex, Mischa Barton—newly single at the time—chose a gold Rubin & Chapelle dress layered with a soft white cardigan. The look leaned modest and vintage-inspired, a noticeable shift from her early-2000s It-girl era alongside Rachel Bilson on The O.C.

While the long silhouette and cozy styling muted her usual red-carpet edge, it reflected Barton’s evolving approach to fashion—more refined, less overtly trend-driven. Since The O.C. ended in 2007, she has kept a relatively low profile, leaving many fans hopeful for a full-fledged comeback to the style spotlight.

Mischa Barton attends the New York premiere of Showtime’s Masters of Sex at the Morgan Library & Museum on September 26, 2013, wearing a gold satin Rubin & Chapelle gown layered with a white cardigan and paired with minimalist black sandals and a metallic clutch (Credit: Joel Ginsburg / Alberto Reyes / Apega / FayesVision / SIPA / WENN)

Stana Katic: Radiance on the Red Carpet

The statuesque Stana flaunted her legs at the CBGB premiere in Los Angeles in a bright pink Versace mini dress paired with Casadei pointy pumps.

She didn’t wear much jewelry for this look and relied on those carefully placed oversized pins for that oomph. We love her short, wavy locks and mile-long legs, too!

Stana Katic exudes effortless glamour at the CBGB premiere in Los Angeles, wearing a fuchsia Versace mini dress detailed with safety pins and styled with matching neon-pink Casadei pointy-toe pumps that elongate her 5’9″ frame on October 1, 2013 (Credit: Joel Ginsburg / Alberto Reyes / Apega / FayesVision / SIPA / WENN)

As both actresses share the same statuesque 5’9” frame and a fondness for elegant heels, it’s no surprise that Your Next Shoes has celebrated their standout footwear moments over the years. From Stana Katic’s red-carpet Casadei pumps to Mischa Barton’s Rubin & Chapelle glam, here are their most stylish features worth revisiting.

👠 Explore Stana Katic & Mischa Barton’s Best Shoe Moments