Carrie Underwood’s Best Crystal Heels: From Sergio Rossi “Cachet” to Andrea Wazen “Antigone”

Since winning American Idol, Carrie Underwood has built a red-carpet reputation for dazzling minidresses, sky-high heels, and legs that seem made for the spotlight.

Across more than a decade in the public eye, the country superstar has repeatedly used statement footwear to anchor her most glamorous looks. Two standout moments—separated by more than ten years—perfectly capture how her style has evolved while staying true to her love of sparkle: a crystal-covered appearance at the Academy of Country Music Awards in 2022 and a glittering shoe moment at the American Idol Season 10 finale in 2011.

Carrie Underwood Dazzles in Andrea Wazen “Antigone” Sandals at the 2022 ACM Awards

A prime example of Underwood’s affinity for sparkling silhouettes came at the 57th Academy of Country Music Awards, held on March 7, 2022, at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas.

Carrie Underwood shows off her toned legs in a crystal-embellished Dolce & Gabbana mini dress and Andrea Wazen “Antigone” PVC sandals at the 57th Academy of Country Music Awards on March 7, 2022, in Las Vegas, Nevada (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)

For the event, she wore a gemstone-encrusted Dolce & Gabbana mini dress that shimmered under the stage lights. But it was her footwear—the architectural Andrea Wazen “Antigone” PVC sandals—that added a modern edge to the classic Nashville glamour.

The heels featured transparent straps trimmed in silver leather, creating the illusion of barely-there support while visually elongating her legs—an effect that has become one of Underwood’s signature red-carpet styling tricks.

Carrie Underwood dazzled in a crystal-embellished Dolce & Gabbana strappy mini dress (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)

She completed the look with glittering jewelry from Le Vian, Yessayan, and Emily P. Wheeler, while her sleek golden waves and smoky eye makeup kept the focus on the dress’s crystal-studded bust and strappy detailing.

Carrie Underwood complements her crystal-embellished mini dress with a sparkling Dolce & Gabbana box clutch (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)

The night proved just as successful musically. Underwood received four nominations and ultimately took home Single of the Year for “If I Didn’t Love You,” her duet with Jason Aldean—a victory she celebrated by changing into a festive rainbow Rami Kadi mini dress whose playful skirt resembled confetti.

More than a decade earlier, Underwood delivered another memorable footwear moment at the Season 10 finale of American Idol in May 2011 at the Nokia Theatre L.A. Live. While the finale featured appearances from stars like Jennifer Lopez, Beyoncé, and Lady Gaga, it was Underwood’s glittering shoes that stole the spotlight.

Carrie Underwood Sparkles in Sergio Rossi “Cachet” Pumps at the 2011 American Idol Finale

Carrie Underwood in a Lorena Sarbu Pre-Fall 2011 mini dress at Fox’s American Idol season 10 finale results show held at Nokia Theatre LA Live in Los Angeles, California on May 25, 2011 (Credit: WENN / AdMedia)

She stepped out in crystal-studded satin slingback pumps by Sergio Rossi, a dazzling pair known as the “Cachet.”

The peep-toe design featured high-shine satin covered in sparkling Swarovski crystals, making them a perfect match for her embellished Lorena Sarbu Pre-Fall 2011 bell-sleeved mini dress.

Carrie Underwood steps out in crystal-studded satin slingback pumps by Sergio Rossi, featuring a peep toe and towering stiletto heel (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)

The shimmering pumps caught the light with every step, while the short hemline highlighted Underwood’s famously toned legs—helping the shoes become one of the most memorable footwear moments of the night.

Carrie Underwood flaunted her legs in a beaded dress by Romanian-born couturier Lorena Sarbu (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)

She later wore the same pair again while performing alongside finalist Lauren Alaina, pairing them with a glittering silver top and white shorts that further showcased the crystal-covered heels.

Carrie Underwood shows off her feet in Sergio Rossi’s ‘Cachet’ crystal-studded satin slingbacks (Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock)

Carrie Underwood’s Sparkling Heel Game Is as Strong as Ever

From crystal-covered platform pumps at the American Idol finale to modern PVC sandals on the ACM Awards red carpet, Carrie Underwood has consistently proven that statement footwear is a defining element of her style.

Whether she’s performing on stage or posing for photographers, the country superstar rarely misses an opportunity to pair dazzling dresses with equally eye-catching heels. Explore more of Carrie Underwood’s most memorable shoe and fashion moments below.