Andrew Garfield’s Love Life and Leading Ladies: A Look at His Star-Studded Romances

Andrew Garfield isn’t just known for his powerful performances in films like The Social Network and Hacksaw Ridge—he’s also earned a reputation as one of Hollywood’s best-dressed leading men.

With his striking red carpet looks, stylish shoe choices, and ever-evolving fashion sense, the British-American actor continues to captivate both audiences and fashion critics alike.

Andrew Garfield looking dapper in a custom Valentino suit with Santoni shoes at the 29th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards held at Fairmont Century Plaza in Los Angeles, California on February 26, 2023 (Credit: BauerGriffin / INSTARimages)

Standing tall at 5ft 10½ (179.1 cm) and wearing a US size 11 shoe, Andrew Garfield is often noticeably taller than his girlfriends—and just as attention-grabbing on the red carpet. Widely recognized for his bold, fashion-forward style, Garfield has moved beyond traditional black tuxedos to favor vibrant, tailored looks, often crafted with stylist Warren Alfie Baker.

Despite his standout style and A-list status, he has remained notably private about his personal life. Still, fans are fascinated by his romantic history and evolving perspective on sexuality, so we’re breaking it all down.

Presenting the Animated Feature Film award at the 2025 Oscars, Andrew Garfield exuded retro charm in a chocolate-brown Gucci suit paired with a silky caramel shirt and deep-brown dress shoes, while Goldie Hawn stunned beside him in a butter-yellow Dolce & Gabbana gown adorned with metallic rhinestones (Credit: Trae Patton / The Academy)

From his on-screen chemistry with Emma Stone to his rumored romances with other celebrities, let’s examine Andrew Garfield’s relationship history and the questions surrounding his sexuality.

Andrew Garfield’s Comments on Sexuality Spark Debate

Andrew Garfield got into trouble with the LGBTQ community after declaring, “I am a gay man right now, pretty much, just without the physical act – that’s all,” and admitting that he watched RuPaul’s Drag Race with friends to prepare for his role as a gay man in 2017.

Andrew Garfield exuded classic charm in a rust-colored suit and floral tie while attending the Angels in America revival afterparty at Espace in New York City on March 25, 2018 (Credit: Lev Radin / Shutterstock)

Portraying Prior Walter: Garfield’s Acclaimed Role in Angels in America

Andrew Garfield once played Prior Walter, a gay man struggling with the reality of AIDS at the pinnacle of the 1980s crisis that cost countless lives in the gay community, in the highly lauded London production of Tony Kushner’s Angels in America.

The Amazing Spider-Man star discussed his preparation for the role during a Q&A panel interview, revealing that his initial “big concern” was “what right do I have to play this wonderful, seminal gay part” as a straight man.

Standing tall at 5ft 10½ (179.1 cm) and wearing a US size 11 shoe, Andrew Garfield looked dapper in a tailored brown three-piece suit and polished brown oxford shoes at the Angels in America revival afterparty at Espace in New York City on March 25, 2018 (Credit: Lev Radin / Shutterstock)

Garfield stated, “As far as I know, I am not a gay man. Maybe I’ll have an awakening later in my life, which I’m sure will be wonderful, and I’ll get to explore that part of the garden, but right now, I’m secluded to my area, which is wonderful as well. I adore it.”

Andrew Garfield’s Evolving Stance on Sexual Orientation

The actor revealed that despite being previously identified as straight, he now perceives his sexuality through a more flexible stance during an exclusive interview with OUT magazine in February 2018.

Garfield said, “Up until this point, I’ve only been sexually attracted to women.”

Andrew Garfield wore a tonal Zegna suit with Christian Louboutin No Penny suede loafers at the 28th Annual Critics’ Choice Awards in Los Angeles, California, on January 15, 2023 (Credit: BauerGriffin / INSTARimages / Cover Images)

The actor added, “My stance toward life, though, is that I always try to surrender to the mystery of not being in charge. I think most people – we’re intrinsically trying to control our experience here, and manage it, and put walls around what we are and who we are.”

He elaborated, “I want to know as much of the garden as possible before I pass. I have an openness to any impulses that may arise within me at any time.” However, he quickly added a clarification, saying, “But, if I were to identify, I would identify as heterosexual.”

Exploring Andrew Garfield’s Star-Studded Relationship History

Despite his best efforts to keep his relationships under wraps, Andrew Garfield has been linked to several stunning women.

Aside from being in a relationship with Emma Stone from 2011 to 2015, Garfield has also been linked with Shannon Woodward, Rita Ora, Susie Abromeit, and Christine Gabel. The actor has also been rumored to be in a relationship with Alyssa Miller and Phoebe Dynevor.

Andrew Garfield cut a striking figure in a terracotta Zegna suit paired with sleek black velvet loafers at the 80th Annual Golden Globe Awards in Los Angeles, California, on January 10, 2023 (Credit: DDP / INSTARimages / Cover Images)

Phoebe Dynevor and Andrew Garfield: A Rumored Romance

According to The Sun, Andrew Garfield and Phoebe Dynevor allegedly connected immediately after meeting at GQ’s Men of the Year Awards in London in November 2022 and starting dating.

An insider told the publication, “Andrew and Phoebe clicked straight away. There was an immediate attraction.”

Phoebe Dynevor stunned in a scallop-trimmed black crop top and fringe-hem skirt from Victoria Beckham’s Spring 2023 collection, paired with ruffled black heels at the 2022 GQ Men of the Year Awards held at The Mandarin Oriental Hyde Park in London on November 16, 2022 (Credit: PA Images / INSTARimages / Cover Images)

The source continued, “They know each other through various acquaintances in the business and have plenty in common. But this is certainly no one-off encounter. After leaving together, they’ve since met up and are acting like a proper couple.”

In an exclusive interview with Life & Style in December 2022, a source mentioned that Garfield was ‘really into’ the Bridgerton actress, who is 12 years his junior, noting that ‘the chemistry between them is crazy.'”

Andrew Garfield looked effortlessly sharp in a classic Ralph Lauren double-breasted suit, paired with polished black dress shoes, at the 2022 GQ Men of the Year Awards held in London (Credit: Doug Peters / PA Images / INSTARimag / Cover Images)

The A-list actors have been in constant communication since they first connected through mutual acquaintances in November 2022, and they are both “super happy” about their developing relationship. The insider said, “She has been seeing him in-between filming, and they call and text non-stop.”

However, Andrew Garfield and Phoebe Dynevor are believed to have split later in 2023. In January 2024, Andrew Garfield was rumored to have started a relationship with model Olivia Brower.

They were spotted embracing and possibly kissing in London as Andrew helped Olivia with her luggage into a taxi outside his home.

Olivia Brower is a model represented by JAG Modeling Agency. She is known for appearing in the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue and working with Intimissimi lingerie and Dorothy Perkins fashion.

The Early Days: Shannon Woodward and Andrew Garfield

In the years leading up to his rise to stardom, Andrew Garfield dated Westworld actress Shannon Woodward for three years, from 2008 to 2011.

The couple reportedly parted ways in 2011 due to Garfield’s hectic schedule filming The Amazing Spider-Man.

Shannon Woodward embraced timeless elegance in a black off-the-shoulder floral gown while attending the 70th Primetime Emmy Awards at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles, California, on September 17, 2018 (Credit: Sara DE Boer / Startraksphoto)

Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield: Hollywood’s Beloved Pair

Andrew Garfield’s most high-profile relationship was with his The Amazing Spider-Man co-star, Emma Stone. The couple met on the movie set and started dating from 2011 to 2015.

Although they tried to keep their relationship private, the paparazzi captured several sweet moments between the couple.

Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone at The Amazing Spider-Man premiere in Moscow, Russia, on June 15, 2012 (Credit: Naumova Ekaterina / Shutterstock)

The pair split up in April 2015, and they did so amicably. After marrying former Saturday Night Live director Dave McCary in 2020, Emma Stone and McCary welcomed their daughter the following year.

Susie Abromeit and Andrew Garfield’s Disneyland Sighting

Actress Susie Abromeit and actor Andrew Garfield were reportedly seen spending time together at Disneyland and getting close in Malibu in September 2018, which sparked suspicions that the two were dating.

Abromeit, a former tennis player who switched to acting, is most known for her roles in Chicago Med and Jessica Jones. Their romance appeared short-lived, with rumors claiming it ended near the end of the year.

Susie Abromeit turned heads in a sleek black asymmetrical mini dress paired with knotted peep-toe heels at UCLA’s Institute of the Environment and Sustainability Annual Gala in Beverly Hills, California, on March 22, 2018 (Credit: Sara De Boer / Startraksphoto)

Rita Ora and Andrew Garfield: A Brief Fling

After her breakup with Abromeit, Andrew Garfield was rumored to have moved on to British singer Rita Ora.

But their relationship would also fizzle out as quickly as it started. After only a few short months together, the stars reportedly parted ways in March 2019.

Rita Ora dazzled in a red Georges Hobeika Spring 2022/23 cutout gown paired with Russell & Bromley’s ‘Hold Up’ platform knee-high boots in red nappa while performing at the American Heart Association’s Go Red for Women Red Dress Collection Concert at Lincoln Center in New York City on February 1, 2023 (Credit: Roger Wong / INSTARimages / Cover Images)

Months before the reported couple’s apparent breakup, Ora avoided a question about her favorite Spider-Man actor in January 2019 after keeping their romance largely under wraps.

Christine Gabel: Andrew Garfield’s Most Private Romance

In the summer of 2019, Christine Gabel, a model and medical student, was allegedly dating Andrew Garfield.

Despite doing an excellent job of keeping their relationship out of the spotlight and away from the paparazzi, the couple was caught holding hands in New York City.

Garfield and Gabel’s relationship would eventually end before November 2021, when he would be linked to Sports Illustrated model Alyssa Miller.

Andrew Garfield standing out in a Gucci floral-embellished velvet suit with a yellow shirt and black dress shoes at the 11th Annual LACMA Art + Film Gala held at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art in Los Angeles, California on November 5, 2022 (Credit: Xavier Collin / ABACA / INSTARimages / Cover Images)

Alyssa Miller: Red Carpet Debut and Sudden Breakup

In November 2021, after being seen together in New York City, Garfield fueled romance rumors with model Alyssa Miller.

The couple looked like they confirmed their relationship in February 2022 when they were caught holding hands after a tennis date in Malibu, California, before Valentine’s Day.

Alyssa Miller radiated elegance in a strapless silver-grey embellished gown paired with a jeweled clutch at the 2010 Angel Ball hosted by Gabrielle’s Angel Foundation for Cancer Research in New York City on October 21, 2010 (Credit: Dara Kushner / INFevents)

That same month, Garfield and Miller stepped out as a couple for the first time in matching black suits at the Screen Actors Guild Awards.

Their breakup was announced just one month later due to their busy schedules. But when Miller addressed the split on Instagram, it seemed they had parted ways amicably.

Tracing the Highlights of Andrew Garfield’s Acting Career

Andrew Garfield is an American-English actor who has had a successful career in film and theater. He started his career on stage and in television shows in the UK before gaining global recognition for his supporting role in The Social Network in 2010.

Garfield played the superhero Spider-Man in The Amazing Spider-Man films and later reprised the role in Spider-Man: No Way Home in 2021.

Andrew Garfield as Peter Parker/Spider-Man in the 2021 superhero film Spider-Man: No Way Home (Credit: Sony Pictures Releasing)

He has been nominated for several prestigious awards, including the Academy Awards, Primetime Emmy Awards, Laurence Olivier Awards, and Golden Globe Awards.

In addition, he has performed on stage, earning nominations and awards for his performances in productions such as Angels in America and Death of a Salesman.

Andrew Garfield looked sharp in a grey plaid double-breasted suit styled with a crisp white shirt and dark leather Chelsea boots at The Hollywood Reporter and SAG-AFTRA’s 74th Annual Primetime Emmy Awards and Emmy Nominees Night, held at the Penthouse at 8899 Beverly in West Hollywood, California, on September 10, 2022 (Credit: Xavier Collin / ABACA / INSTARimages / Cover Images)

The Future of Andrew Garfield: New Roles and Creative Moves

In April 2022, Andrew Garfield announced that he would “rest for a little bit” after starring in the true-crime drama TV series Under the Banner of Heaven.

The actor said, “I need to recalibrate and reconsider what I want to do next and who I want to be and just be a bit of a person for a while.”

Andrew Garfield in a Valentino Pre-Fall 2022 After Club look at the Valentino Fall 2022 Haute Couture show during Rome Fashion Week in Rome, Italy on July 8, 2022 (Credit: Marco Piovanotto / ABACA / INSTARimages / Cover Images)

While fans had been eagerly awaiting his next move, it was officially announced in May 2025 that Andrew Garfield is teaming up with Jude Law for Wild Things, an upcoming Apple TV+ limited series based on the legendary magician duo Siegfried & Roy. Jude will portray Siegfried, while Andrew takes on the role of Roy. Both stars will also serve as executive producers on the project, adding creative weight to their performances.

Garfield is also set to appear in an upcoming psychological drama directed by Luca Guadagnino, starring alongside Julia Roberts, Ayo Edebiri, Michael Stuhlbarg, and Chloë Sevigny. The film, scheduled for release on October 10, 2025, follows a college professor at a personal and professional crossroads after a student’s accusation threatens to unearth a haunting secret from her past.

In his personal life, Andrew Garfield was also making headlines in 2025 for reportedly dating actress Monica Barbaro, known for her breakout role in Top Gun: Maverick.

Stepping Out in Style: Shoe Highlights of Garfield’s Leading Ladies

From red carpet glam to street-style statements, Andrew Garfield’s current and former partners have showcased standout footwear moments. Here are some of their most memorable looks:

Emma Stone’s Chic Two-Tone Ensemble at the 2025 Film Independent Spirit Awards

• Event: 2025 Film Independent Spirit Awards
• Outfit: Emma Stone opted for a chic two-tone Emilia Wickstead dress, showcasing her effortless style.
• Footwear: She completed the look with sleek black pumps, adding a touch of elegance to her ensemble.
• Read more: Emma Stone Elevates Spring Style in Chic Two-Tone Emilia Wickstead Dress and Black Pumps

Rita Ora’s Bold Street Style in Pink Nike Air Max DN8 Sneakers

• Event: Street Style in Milan
• Outfit: Rita Ora turned heads in a layered ensemble featuring a denim skirt over blue pants and a vintage rice sack shirt.
• Footwear: She added a pop of color with vibrant pink Nike Air Max DN8 sneakers, showcasing her bold fashion sense.
• See more: Rita Ora Blends Denim Skirt With Blue Pants and the New Pink Nike Air Max DN8 Shoes

Alyssa Miller’s Edgy Look at the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Event

• Event: Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Event
• Outfit: Alyssa Miller stood out in a modern knee-length dress with patent detailing, exuding contemporary elegance.
• Footwear: She paired the dress with sleek heels, completing her edgy look.
• Discover more: Alyssa Miller Stands Out in a Modern Knee-Length Dress With Patent Detailing

Phoebe Dynevor’s Daring Look at the 2023 Critics’ Choice Awards

• Event: 2023 Critics’ Choice Awards
• Outfit: Phoebe Dynevor made a stunning entrance in a daringly low-cut nude Louis Vuitton outfit featuring a hand-painted pastel flower motif.
• Footwear: She complemented the look with elegant heels, enhancing her sophisticated appearance.
• See her look: Phoebe Dynevor in Louis Vuitton at the 2023 Critics’ Choice Awards

Monica Barbaro’s Role in ‘FUBAR’ Highlights Her Stature

• Project: ‘FUBAR’ Series
• Role: Monica Barbaro portrays Emma Brunner, an ambitious CIA agent, showcasing her acting prowess.
• Details: Standing at 5ft 7in (170.2 cm), Monica brings both talent and presence to her role.
• Learn more: Monica Barbaro’s Height and Role in ‘FUBAR’

These stylish moments highlight the fashion-forward choices of Andrew Garfield’s current and former partners, each making their mark with distinctive footwear and ensembles.